As I have read, there is a not a huge success rate with embryo transfer. Can anyone tell me why this is? What is the physiology/anatomy behind the problem? I'm applying to an M.S. program in theriogenology, and this might be a problem that I'm interested in researching. I need a place to start from, though. Thanks!
Andrea Jos is certainly more knowledgeable than I in this area, but I think the information you have is based on industry averages rather than facility averages. Included in those industry averages are those many instances where, one two or just a few mares are done and often by people who do not routinely perform this procedure. In addition they are often performed, not at a dedicated facility but on a farm or in a practitioner's clinic where this is not a routine procedure. Across the industry the conception rates are comparatively low for a whole host of reasons not directly attributable to the procedure it's self.
Actually when the procedure is performed in a facility that is set up to do it and both the donor and recipients are under the control of these people. That rates are actually quite good. As with many forms of reproduction where their is a human factor added to the equation. Frequently it's the human factor that adversely affects the overall result. Professional reproductive personnel excepted.
In the case of embryo transfer, the use of mares that are not prime donors is probably the largest negative factor. The second would probably be the difficulty of synchronizing the recipients with the donors and having a sufficient number of quality recipients available. Other than those things, the procedure it's self is relatively simple and effective.
I know of a facility that for a number of years consistently had a very high conception rate. However it was a dedicated facility that only did embryo transfer and nothing else.
Horse Pro, Thanks for the information. I guess I probably need to do more reading before I can figure out where to base my research project in graduate school. If anyone has any suggestions, please let me know!
Posted on Tuesday, February 13, 2001 - 09:21 pm:
Embryo transfer is prone to failure in different ways in each of its stages. These different failures will all affect the overall statistical analysis.
Firstly of course, one has to get the mare pregnant; then there has to be a conceptus that has descended into the uterus by the time the harvest is planned (usually day 6 or 7); then you've got to successfully flush the embryo and find it; it must be washed and analysed for quality - not all embryos are of suitable quality for transfer; once you have successfully managed all that, the transfer itself has to be successful and then the recipient mare has to be gracious enough to retain the pregnancy.
As you can see, a failure at any stage is going to compromise the whole operation and statistical analysis.
I think the average for obtaining a successfully transplanted and maintained embryo is somthing like 2.5 flushes/transfers - which considering all the possible failures actually isn't too awfully bad!
On top of all the potential procedure problems, one has to add technician failure - and there is no doubt whatsoever that some are more successful than others at performing the procedure.
Has any one got a list of statistics for embryo transfer success rates compared to that of artificial insemination? I know that each horse is very different but just as a law of averages would be great. i am duing a reseach assignment on the different artificial breeding techniques in showjumpers. I need to know the pros and con of both the A.I method and Embryo transfers. If this is possible the information would be much appreciated. thank you. jane wickham.
Posted on Wednesday, March 07, 2001 - 12:36 am:
You cannot compare AI to ET as they are like apples and oranges - both advanced breeding processes but not the same. The statistics for AI relate to pregnancies achieved, whereas with ET the pregnancy has already been achieved and it is the successful flushing and transfer rate that is important.
There is more information about AI on this site available by clicking here.
ET statistics are even more variable with the success rate highly "technician dependent". Generally it takes a little over 2 flushes to obtain an embryo on the average; and a further 2 transfers to achieve a maintained pregnancy. These however are only averages and as I say are highly technician-dependent.
Iím a Brazilian veterinarian and my specialty is non-surgical equine embryo transfers. I have been doing embryo transfer for over 4 years and have done over 150 successful procedures in farms across Brazil. I can confidently say that my conception rate is over 80%, depending mostly on the quality of the mares (age, proper nourishment, etc). I am looking for the possibility of spending some time abroad to explore new ventures. I can be reached at: firstname.lastname@example.org
Please note that opinions, product information, advice or suggestions posted on this bulletin board are not necessarily those of the management at Equine-Reproduction.com nor does the maintenance of the post position indicate an implicit or any endorsement of that information, opinion or product.
Further, although we have the greatest respect for the posters offering assistance here, you are advised to seek a consultation with your veterinarian prior to using information obtained from this board if it is of a veterinary nature.Proud to be sponsored and supported by: